started · updated
Rio de Janeiro Governor Election: Zanin denies PSD request for second round
Supreme Court Minister Cristiano Zanin has denied a preliminary injunction requested by the PSD party to reinstate a second round in the Rio de Janeiro gubernatorial election. The decision maintains Douglas Ruas (PL) as the winner of the first round.
The dispute stems from a decision by the Superior Electoral Court (TSE) to annul 274,411 votes cast for Anthony Garotinho (Republicanos) after his candidacy was declared invalid. Following the removal of these votes from the calculation, Ruas's vote share rose from 49.27% to 50.88%, surpassing the absolute majority required to win in the first round. The PSD, representing candidate Eduardo Paes, argues that Garotinho's votes should remain in the base calculation for determining the need for a second round since the candidacy was still under judicial review when voters went to the polls.
Zanin ruled that the PSD used an improper legal instrument, characterizing the use of an ADPF (Allegation of Violation of a Fundamental Precept) as an attempt to bypass standard electoral appeals. The Attorney General's Office (AGU) also expressed opposition to the PSD's request, stating that the matter should first be resolved through the TSE, where appeals are still pending. While the injunction was denied, the merits of the case have not yet been judged.
Entities
Anthony Garotinho · Cristiano Zanin · Douglas Ruas · Eduardo Paes · Supreme Federal Court · Supremo Tribunal Federal
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 30 SOURCES] The PSD party argues that Garotinho's votes should be included in the calculation for determining the need for a second round. extra.globo.com · ndmais.com.br · www.osaogoncalo.com.br · noticiabrasil.net.br · oantagonista.com.br · +21 more
- [● 3 SOURCES] The TRE-RJ retotalized votes for state deputies, resulting in the PL losing one seat. www.osaogoncalo.com.br
- [● 14 SOURCES] Two motions for clarification (embargos de declaração) are pending before the TSE regarding the election result. oantagonista.com.br · exame.com · www.osaogoncalo.com.br · errejotanoticias.com.br · www.metropoles.com · +7 more
- [● 30 SOURCES] The TSE annulled 274,411 votes received by Anthony Garotinho. extra.globo.com · ndmais.com.br · www.osaogoncalo.com.br · noticiabrasil.net.br · oantagonista.com.br · +21 more
- [● 26 SOURCES] Following the annulment of Garotinho's votes, Douglas Ruas reached 50.88% of valid votes. extra.globo.com · ndmais.com.br · exame.com · painelpolitico.com · paraonline.com.br · +17 more
- [● 30 SOURCES] STF Minister Cristiano Zanin denied the PSD party's request for a second round in the Rio de Janeiro gubernatorial election. extra.globo.com · ndmais.com.br · www.osaogoncalo.com.br · noticiabrasil.net.br · oantagonista.com.br · +20 more
- [● 28 SOURCES] Zanin characterized the PSD's legal action as an improper use of an ADPF as a substitute for electoral appeals. extra.globo.com · www.osaogoncalo.com.br · noticiabrasil.net.br · oantagonista.com.br · oglobo.globo.com · +19 more
- [● 3 SOURCES] Luiz Antonio Martins (PSDB/Cidadania) was elected to the Rio de Janeiro State Assembly following the vote recount. www.osaogoncalo.com.br