started · updated
San Francisco Judge Harry Dorfman faces criticism for using racial slur in court
San Francisco Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman is facing criticism from Black attorneys for his repeated use of the N-word during courtroom proceedings. The judge, who was appointed by a Democratic governor, has been accused of reciting the racial slur in full rather than using abbreviations when quoting evidence or discussing cases.
Black public defenders have expressed significant distress regarding the practice. Deputy Public Defender Phoenix Streets noted that hearing the slur evoked traumatic childhood memories of racial harassment. In one instance, when a defense attorney attempted to refer to the term without stating it fully, Dorfman allegedly instructed the lawyer to say the entire word.
In 2022, San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju filed a complaint alleging that Dorfman failed to recognize the trauma caused by the word's utterance and neglected to use alternatives that could preserve the court record without repetition. Despite these complaints, no disciplinary action was taken against Dorfman, and the San Francisco Superior Court declined to intervene.
Entities
Harry Dorfman · Mano Raju · Phoenix Streets · San Francisco Superior Court