API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · United Kingdom · 2 sources

started · updated

Scottish Court rules Information Commissioner erred in Salmond files order

A panel of three judges at the Court of Session has ruled that the Scottish Information Commissioner, David Hamilton, “erred in law” when he ordered Scottish Government ministers to disclose exempted material regarding the Hamilton Inquiry.

The inquiry was launched by former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon to investigate whether there was a breach of the ministerial code concerning the Holyrood inquiry into Alex Salmond. Ministers appealed the disclosure order, arguing that releasing the material could lead to the identification of complainants involved in Salmond’s previous criminal trial, in which he was cleared of all charges.

The court upheld the ministers’ appeal, stating that a breach of court orders occurs if the disclosure of information produces a “real or substantial risk of identification.” The judges noted that even if the information only allows for assumptions regarding identities, such risks heighten the danger of identification and could constitute contempt of court.

Entities

Alex Salmond · Court of Session · David Hamilton · Nicola Sturgeon · Scottish Information Commissioner