API
< Back to all clusters
[BUSINESS] · Brazil · 2 sources

started · updated

São Paulo Court sets average R$ 9.6k indemnity for denied urgent health treatments

The Court of Justice of São Paulo (TJ-SP) has established an average moral damages indemnity of R$ 9,579.71 in cases where health insurance providers improperly deny coverage for urgent or emergency treatments and surgeries.

A study of 276 second-instance decisions issued between July 2025 and July 2026 reveals that these indemnities rarely exceed R$ 10,000, excluding interest and monetary correction. The R$ 9,579.71 figure appeared in 51.1% of the analyzed cases, while R$ 5,000 and R$ 8,000 were also frequent amounts.

Commonly denied procedures include emergency childbirth, ICU admissions for sepsis, stroke, or respiratory failure, cardiac surgeries, and oncological treatments such as chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Other denied services include emergency abdominal and urological surgeries, such as appendectomies and kidney stone removals.

In most instances, health operators argued that beneficiaries had not met contractual waiting periods (carência). However, judges ruled these arguments invalid and abusive, citing the Health Insurance Law, which mandates a maximum 24-hour waiting period for urgent and emergency situations. Judges determined indemnity values based on the principles of proportionality and reasonableness.

Entities

Court of Justice of São Paulo