started · updated
São Paulo Court suspends tax rulings on IBS and CBS inclusion
The Court of Justice of São Paulo (TJ-SP) has suspended rulings that allowed companies to exclude the Imposto sobre Bens e Serviços (IBS) and the Contribuição sobre Bens e Serviços (CBS) from the ICMS calculation base starting in 2027. The decision, issued by Court President Francisco Loureiro, follows a request from the state treasury citing potential revenue risks during the tax reform transition.
The São Paulo Treasury estimates that excluding these new taxes could result in an annual loss of R$ 10.2 billion for the state in 2027, including a R$ 2.55 billion reduction in constitutional transfers to the state's 645 municipalities. The dispute centers on the interpretation of the Kandir Law, with the state arguing that the tax base must include all taxes comprising the price charged to the buyer, while companies contend that IBS and CBS have distinct structures that should not be integrated into the ICMS base without express legal provision.
This decision does not conclude the legal debate regarding the legality of including these new taxes in the state tax calculation.
Entities
Court of Justice of São Paulo · Francisco Loureiro · São Paulo State Treasury