started · updated
South Korean Supreme Court rules on corporate liability for music copyright
The Supreme Court of South Korea has ruled that parent companies cannot be held liable for music copyright infringements occurring at franchise or agency locations unless they can prove they gained specific economic benefits from the unauthorized music playback.
In a case involving Hankook Tire and Technology, the Korea Music Copyright Association (KOMCA) sought damages for music played at Tire Station locations between 2009 and 2016. While lower courts previously ordered the company to pay damages, the Supreme Court overturned the decision, stating that since franchisees are the actual operators, the parent company must demonstrate how the music playback directly contributed to its own profits, such as through increased franchise fees or brand recognition.
The court applied similar logic to a lawsuit against LG Electronics regarding music played at LG Best Shop stores. The court ruled that even if a subsidiary operates the stores, the parent company is a separate legal entity. Therefore, LG Electronics cannot be held responsible for unjust enrichment unless it is proven that the company received substantial practical benefits from the music services provided at those locations.
Entities
Hankook Tire & Technology · Korea Music Copyright Association · LG Best Shop · LG Electronics · Supreme Court of Korea · Supreme Court of South Korea