API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · United States · 3 sources

started · updated

Supreme Court hears arguments in Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the case of Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, focusing on whether the Executive Branch has the authority to levy civil penalties regarding immigration contracts.

Sun Valley Orchards is appealing a $550,000 fine issued by the Department of Labor in 2015. The fine followed an inspection that found the farm violated H-2A seasonal agricultural worker program rules concerning living conditions. The company argues that such civil penalties relate to contract law and should be adjudicated in courts under Article Three of the Constitution, rather than through the Department of Labor’s internal processes.

During arguments, justices from both sides of the ideological spectrum questioned the company’s legal position. Associate Justice Elena Kagan noted that the H-2A program is fundamentally an immigration program designed to manage the admission of foreign workers and protect the economic status of domestic workers. Associate Justice Brett Kavanaugh also questioned the scope of the company’s argument regarding the adjudication of all civil penalties.

Entities

Brett Kavanaugh · Department of Labor · Elena Kagan · Sun Valley Orchards · Supreme Court of the United States