started · updated
Supreme Court Justice Gilmar Mendes addresses pejotização legality
Supreme Federal Court (STF) Justice Gilmar Mendes indicated that the Labor Court should maintain competence to analyze cases involving potential fraud in service contracts through legal entities, a practice known as pejotização. Speaking at a union event in São Paulo, Mendes, the rapporteur for Theme 1,389, stated that the STF's role is not to broadly prohibit or authorize the model, but to establish secure criteria for the Labor Court to assess the legitimacy of each specific case.
Pejotização occurs when a professional establishes a legal entity to provide services to a company instead of being hired under the formal Consolidation of Labor Laws (CLT) regime. While the STF has previously recognized the legality of outsourcing economic activities and the division of labor between distinct legal entities, concerns persist regarding the use of civil contracts to disguise traditional employment relationships characterized by subordination, personal service, and remuneration.
The upcoming judgment of Theme 1,389 is expected to define central questions, including which branch of the judiciary is competent to handle fraud allegations in these service contracts and the validity of hiring autonomous workers or companies for service execution.
Entities
Brazil · Gilmar Mendes · Labor Court · Supreme Federal Court