started · updated
Supreme Court Justice María Estela Ríos disputes methodology in judicial session
Supreme Court Justice María Estela Ríos González confronted her colleagues during a plenary session of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN). The dispute arose during the discussion of a project regarding the judicial intervention of private communications.
Ríos González requested that her decision and methodology be respected after several ministers proposed modifications to her proposal to align it with the majority's criteria. The disagreement centered on a draft ruling concerning an appeal against provisions of the Telecommunications and Broadcasting Law.
While the other ministers agreed with the general sense of the resolution, they sought to change the legal argumentation. Ríos González characterized these requests as an imposition and suggested her project be rejected so the case could be reassigned. Her request was denied, and Chief Justice Hugo Aguilar Ortiz intervened to state that the discussion aimed to reach a consensus supported by the majority.
Entities
Hugo Aguilar Ortiz · María Estela Ríos González · Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation