started · updated
Supreme Court of India rules grandson has no birthright in father's partitioned property
The Supreme Court of India has ruled that a grandson does not acquire a right by birth to property that a father inherited through a partition of a grandfather's estate. A bench comprising Justice Augustine George Masih and Justice Sunita Agarwal dismissed an appeal filed by a minor, through his mother, seeking a half share in land located in Chennai.
The Court clarified that once property is devolved upon Class I heirs under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and subsequently partitioned, the share allotted to the father becomes his exclusive property held in an individual capacity. The bench noted that the property loses its coparcenary character following such a partition.
The ruling emphasized that the express language of Section 8 must prevail. While pre-1956 personal Hindu law allowed for a grandson's rights in a grandfather's property during the father's lifetime, the Court observed that the legislature did not expressly save this right when enacting the Hindu Succession Act. The appellant's claim, which sought partition of land sold by his father in 1997, was rejected, upholding previous decisions by the First Appellate Court and the Madras High Court.
Entities
Augustine George Masih · Chennai · Madras High Court · Sunita Agarwal · Supreme Court of India