started · updated
Supreme Court of India rules sales tax surcharge is within state competence
A seven-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court of India has ruled that states possess the legal competence to impose an additional tax or surcharge calculated as a percentage of existing sales tax. The court clarified that such a levy constitutes an enhancement of the sales tax rate rather than a tax on a dealer's income.
The ruling addresses a constitutional reference that has been pending since 1999. The court determined that the specific question referred to it has become academic because the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime has since replaced the previous constitutional entries and state laws that governed the original dispute.
While the court disposed of the reference without fresh adjudication due to these legislative changes, it upheld the binding nature of the 1974 S Kodar versus State of Kerala judgment. This precedent confirms that taxing the sale or purchase of goods remains within the legislative authority of states under Entry 54 of List II.
Entities
Goods and Services Tax · KV Viswanathan · Supreme Court of India · Surya Kant