API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · Switzerland · 3 sources

started · updated

Swiss Federal Court faces internal rift over judges' relationship ruling

The Swiss Federal Court is experiencing significant internal tension following a ruling regarding an impermissible relationship between two judges, Yves Donzallaz and Beatrice van de Graaf. The affair was deemed inadmissible, leading to questions about judicial conduct and procedural integrity.

Federal Judge Florence Aubry Girardin reportedly boycotted a preparatory session involving all eight divisions of the court, calling the meeting “senseless” and an attempt to maintain a “semblance of procedural guarantees.” She expressed shock at the proceedings, arguing that the court should not decide on legal questions behind closed doors that would subsequently bind the division deliberating in public.

The controversy centers on whether a prohibited relationship can trigger a revision of a case and how strictly a “permanent life partnership” must be defined. The internal disagreement highlights a deep divide within the country's highest court regarding legal principles and the fairness of the judicial process.

Entities

Beatrice van de Graaf · Florence Aubry Girardin · Swiss Federal Court · Yves Donzallaz