API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · Switzerland · 3 sources

started · updated

Swiss judicial commission recommends Beatrice van de Graaf for reelection

The Swiss judicial commission has recommended the reelection of Federal Judge Beatrice van de Graaf, despite a ruling that her relationship with fellow judge Yves Donzallaz violated legal incompatibility rules. The decision was reached by a narrow 9 to 7 vote.

During the commission proceedings, Yves Donzallaz withdrew his candidacy for another term. Commission President Leo Müller stated that while the judges maintained a permanent domestic partnership that was prohibited under the Federal Supreme Court Act, the violation was not severe enough to warrant a recommendation against reelection. Müller noted that the judges only became aware of the legal implications of their relationship later in time.

The Federal Supreme Court had previously determined in a pilot proceeding that the relationship between the two judges constituted a violation of statutory rules. The final confirmation of van de Graaf's reelection rests with the United Federal Assembly, consisting of both the National Council and the Council of States.

Entities

Beatrice van de Graaf · Leo Müller · Swiss Federal Supreme Court · United Federal Assembly · Yves Donzallaz