started · updated
Brazilian Senate faces criticism over R$ 6 million iPhone contract
The Brazilian Senate is facing intense political scrutiny over a R$ 6.04 million bidding process for mobile telephony services. The contract, scheduled to begin in February 2027, includes the provision of 425 smartphones through a bailment (comodato) arrangement, meaning the devices are loaned by the service provider rather than purchased by the state.
The plan includes 95 high-end iPhone 18 Pro models for senators and directors, alongside 330 intermediate Android devices for staff. The contract covers a four-year period and includes data plans, international roaming, and equipment replacement every two years to prevent technological obsolescence.
Federal Deputy Tabata Amaral has petitioned the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) to suspend the bidding, alleging that the specification of luxury brands and the high cost lack economic justification and violate laws against unnecessary luxury spending. Conversely, Senate President Davi Alcolumbre defended the move, stating that the bailment model is a standard practice for government agencies to ensure technical compatibility and service continuity. He noted that senators are not obligated to use the provided devices and may opt out.
Entities
Apple · Açailândia · Brazilian Senate · Davi Alcolumbre · Federal Court of Accounts · Nikolas Ferreira · Olho D’Água das Cunhãs · Olindo Chaves Municipal Slaughterhouse · Public Ministry of Maranhão · Senado Federal · Tabata Amaral · Tribunal de Contas da União