started · updated
Tata Power faces scrutiny over Rs 5,500-crore arbitration award
Former Supreme Court Justice Vineet Saran has raised concerns regarding a Singapore-seated arbitral tribunal’s decision to award over Rs 5,500 crore (approximately $550 million) to Kleros against Tata Power. The dispute stems from a proposed coal-mining project in Russia.
Justice Saran questioned the basis of the damages, noting reports that Kleros had neither made substantial investments nor executed the proposed project, referring to the entity as a ‘Letter Box Company.’ He argued that the compensation appeared to rely on assumptions of future profits rather than actual project execution or investment.
The tribunal's decision shows a significant internal divergence. While the majority assessed compensation at roughly $490.32 million including interest, the Indian arbitrator, Justice A. K. Ganguly, valued the damages at approximately $13.5 million. Additionally, Justice Saran and former Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi have raised questions regarding potential conflicts of interest and the handling of bias allegations against members of the tribunal.
Entities
Justice A. K. Ganguly · Justice Vineet Saran · Kleros · Mukul Rohatgi · Tata Power