started · updated
Tata Sons reappoints N Chandrasekaran amid shareholder dispute
N Chandrasekaran has been reappointed as the Chairman of Tata Sons for a third five-year term, a decision that has triggered a dispute between the company's board and its majority shareholder, Tata Trusts.
The reappointment followed a split vote among board members. Of the five members voting, four supported the move, while Noel Tata, a nominee of Tata Trusts, voted against it. Because the vote was tied among the relevant directors, a casting vote was exercised by the chairman pro tem, Harish Manwani, to secure Chandrasekaran’s reappointment.
Noel Tata, who chairs Tata Trusts—the entity holding 66 per cent of Tata Sons' shares—has challenged the decision, calling it a ‘legal nullity’. He argues that the company’s Articles of Association require affirmative support from a majority of the Tata Trusts-nominated directors, a requirement he claims was not met.
However, legal opinions from former Supreme Court judges Justice BN Srikrishna and Justice Uday U Lalit support the validity of the appointment. The opinions suggest that the requirement for a Selection Committee applies to new appointments rather than the reappointment of an incumbent, and that the casting vote used to break the tie was consistent with the company’s Articles of Association.
Entities
N Chandrasekaran · Noel Tata · Tata Sons · Tata Trusts · Venu Srinivasan