started · updated
Tuscany TAR upholds in-house water service model for Medio Valdarno
The Tuscany TAR has rejected an appeal by Acque Blu Fiorentine, a company controlled by Acea, regarding the decision by the Tuscan Water Authority (Ait) to implement an in-house providing model for integrated water services in Medio Valdarno starting in 2027.
The court ruled that the indirect control exercised through Plures, the controlling shareholder of Publiacqua, is a legitimate way for municipalities to maintain oversight. The court distinguished between the choice of the management model and the final assignment of the service, noting that the verification of the operator's specific requirements can be addressed in a subsequent decision by the Ait.
The ruling follows a report from the Italian Competition Authority (Agcm) which identified certain critical issues in the assignment process. However, the Ait maintains that its choice of the in-house model is analytically motivated to consolidate local government presence and ensure that profits are reinvested into infrastructure and social support policies, such as water bonuses.
Entities
Acea · Acque Blu Fiorentine · Publiacqua · Tuscan Water Authority · Tuscany TAR