started · updated
U.S. commentators argue Juneteenth, not July 4th, should be the true Independence Day
Journalist Joy Reid urged that Juneteenth replace the Fourth of July as America’s true Independence Day, saying many Black Americans do not celebrate the traditional holiday and citing Frederick Douglass’s critique of July 4th as a celebration of slaveholders.
A series of essays in Nonprofit Quarterly examined both holidays together, arguing that the nation’s founding compromises—especially the Three‑Fifths Compromise—embedded racial caste into the architecture of American democracy. The analysis traces how slavery and later segregation preserved a hierarchy that continues to shape political and economic power, suggesting a need to reckon with this legacy when considering national symbols of freedom.