API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · United States · 2 sources

started · updated

US Department of Justice appeals decision on NYC congestion pricing

The US Department of Justice is appealing a court decision regarding the Trump administration’s attempt to block congestion pricing in New York City. The appeal follows a March ruling by Judge Lewis Liman in favor of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), which had sued the federal government to protect the Manhattan toll program.

In legal filings, the Department of Justice has presented two primary arguments. First, officials contend that Judge Liman lacked jurisdiction because the matter constitutes a dispute over a financial contract. Second, the government argues that the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) possesses the inherent power to reconsider and revoke its approvals to adjust to changing priorities or circumstances.

Legal experts have questioned these claims, noting that the agreement authorizing the program under the Value Pricing Pilot Program lacks a specific clause allowing for unilateral revocation. Critics argue that an agency cannot simply change its mind regardless of the underlying statute or the correctness of the original decision.

Entities

Department of Justice · Federal Highway Administration · Lewis Liman · Metropolitan Transportation Authority · New York City