started · updated
U.S. Supreme Court hears climate liability arguments in Suncor v. Boulder
The U.S. Supreme Court has opened its new term by hearing oral arguments in Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder County. The case centers on a lawsuit filed in 2018 by the city and county of Boulder, Colorado, which seeks to hold Suncor Energy and ExxonMobil liable for damages related to climate change, including extreme heat, wildfires, and floods.
Energy companies argue that the lawsuit should be dismissed because federal law, specifically the Clean Air Act, preempts state-level claims regarding air pollution and environmental regulation. They contend that such state-level tort suits represent an unprecedented attempt to regulate global conduct through local courts. Conversely, Boulder officials argue they are seeking compensation for specific local harms caused by alleged deceptive marketing and the environmental impacts of fossil fuels, rather than attempting to set national emissions policy.
Justice Samuel Alito recused himself from the case, raising the possibility of a 4-4 deadlock. If the Court ties, the previous ruling by the Colorado Supreme Court—which allowed the case to proceed in state court—would stand. The decision could have significant implications for dozens of similar climate-related lawsuits filed by municipalities and states across the country.
Entities
Boulder · Boulder County · Boulder, Colorado · Environmental Protection Agency · Exxon Mobil · ExxonMobil · John Roberts · Samuel Alito · Suncor Energy · U.S. Supreme Court
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 20 SOURCES] The defendants are asking the Supreme Court to rule that only federal courts have jurisdiction over these climate-related matters. www.humanite.fr · www.lesaffaires.com · newsone.com · www.singtaousa.com · eos.org · +10 more
- [● 10 SOURCES] Energy companies argue that the Clean Air Act grants the EPA exclusive authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions. www.humanite.fr · www.lesaffaires.com · www.singtaousa.com · eos.org · newsone.com · +4 more
- [● 23 SOURCES] Boulder County and City filed a lawsuit in 2018 against Suncor Energy and Exxon Mobil alleging they knew fossil fuels would cause environmental harm. www.humanite.fr · www.lesaffaires.com · newsone.com · www.singtaousa.com · www.upreg.fr · +14 more
- [● 19 SOURCES] The plaintiffs seek hundreds of millions of dollars in damages for losses from climate-related wildfires, floods, and extreme weather. www.humanite.fr · www.lesaffaires.com · newsone.com · www.singtaousa.com · eos.org · +11 more
- [● 7 SOURCES] Suncor Energy's counsel argued that the lawsuit is an unprecedented attempt to use state law to regulate global activities. www.lesaffaires.com · www.singtaousa.com · eos.org · 92q.com · kahawatungu.com · +1 more
- [● 26 SOURCES] The U.S. Supreme Court began its new term by hearing arguments regarding climate liability lawsuits. www.humanite.fr · www.lesaffaires.com · newsone.com · www.singtaousa.com · eos.org · +16 more
- [● 10 SOURCES] Justice Samuel Alito recused himself from the case. onecaribbeantelevision.com · internewscast.com · www.commondreams.org · laopinion.com · www.europesays.com · +3 more
- [● 18 SOURCES] The Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Suncor Energy v. Boulder. onecaribbeantelevision.com · internewscast.com · legal-planet.org · www.commondreams.org · www.europesays.com · +11 more