Vikings pick Kyler Murray as starter, J.J. McCarthy improves markedly

The Minnesota Vikings entered training camp with a clear quarterback competition between veteran Kyler Murray and first‑round pick J.J. McCarthy. Former NFL lineman Joe Thomas said the organization has already decided Murray will be the starter and McCarthy will begin the season as the backup.

Despite being slated as the number two, McCarthy has shown significant progress. ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler reported that the Vikings asked him to improve his ball‑layering and ability to vary throw speeds, and McCarthy “addressed that in a major way.” Wide receiver Justin Jefferson noted McCarthy’s smarter reads and more precise, touch‑based throws after a year of development. While Murray remains the frontrunner, his performance and McCarthy’s improvement keep the decision open for the coaching staff.

Both former players offered contrasting opinions on Murray’s hype, with LeSean McCoy questioning the quarterback’s consistency. The ongoing evaluation will shape the Vikings’ offensive strategy as the 2025 season approaches.