started · updated
Xiamen court rejects surveillance footage in divorce case
A court in Xiamen, Fujian province, has ruled that surveillance footage recorded by a wife to document her husband’s alleged infidelity cannot be used as evidence in their divorce proceedings. The woman, identified as Ms. Wu, installed hidden cameras in the family bedroom, capturing more than 80 instances of her husband, He Lei (a pseudonym), engaging in intimate contact with various women over a three-month period.
While Ms. Wu attempted to use the videos and detailed logs to prove marital misconduct, the first-instance court rejected the materials. The court ruled that the method of obtaining the evidence seriously infringed upon the privacy rights of others and violated public order and good morals. Citing the Civil Code and Supreme People’s Court interpretations, the court stated that evidence obtained through methods that severely violate legal prohibitions or public morality is inadmissible.
The ruling emphasized that marriage does not grant one spouse the right to unilaterally strip or restrict the other’s privacy. The court noted that the continuous, indiscriminate, and secret recording in a bedroom setting was disproportionate to the wife’s stated goal of monitoring her husband’s behavior. Ms. Wu has appealed the decision, with a second-instance hearing expected in late November.