This situation has concluded
It was preserved as a record on October 15; the timeline below shows how it unfolded, with sources. Get the briefing to follow the top situations still developing: three emails a week, sourced and in order.
Unsubscribe anytime.
[SITUATION] · [QUIET] · [POLITICS]
7 clusters · 110 sources · 26 days · First seen · Last updated
Judge allows Pentagon to fire Stars and Stripes staff
Overview
The Pentagon has dismissed several key leaders of Stars and Stripes, a newspaper serving U.S. military personnel, on charges of insubordination. The terminations include editor-in-chief Erik Slavin, publisher Max Lederer Jr., and Middle East reporter Lara Korte. Those dismissed indicated their removals were linked to their defense of editorial independence. Slavin noted the Pentagon cited insubordination after he described potential news censorship for service members as a ‘red line’ during a CBS interview. Korte stated her professional loyalty lies with the newspaper rather than the Pentagon. Lederer, who had planned to retire in September, cited fundamental differences in mission and leadership philosophy with the Department of Defense. He also claimed the Pentagon installed an active-duty service member as a deputy publisher without his knowledge. The dismissals follow reports by the publication regarding difficult conditions for Navy sailors aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln. Speaking in Tokyo on September 14, Lederer asserted that coverage of the USS Abraham Lincoln—which detailed food and water shortages, mail delays, and excessive work hours during a 270-day deployment—served as the ‘tipping point’ for the Pentagon’s decision. In response, the three former leaders filed a 45-page federal lawsuit in Washington, D.C., against the Pentagon and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, alleging their firings violated First Amendment rights and constituted retaliation for their journalism. On September 4, U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden ruled that the Pentagon may proceed with the terminations, denying the plaintiffs' request for a temporary restraining order. Judge McFadden found the journalists were unlikely to prove a violation of their First Amendment rights, noting the dismissals were based on insubordination related to interviews conducted as part of their official duties.
Entities
Stars and Stripes · Erik Slavin · Pentagon · Max Lederer · Pete Hegseth
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 18 SOURCES] The employees were terminated for insubordination. offthepress.com · internewscast.com · srnnews.com · abc17news.com · keyt.com · +13 more
- [● 11 SOURCES] The dismissals followed reporting on poor conditions aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln. www.chinesepress.com · ca.news.yahoo.com · www.hawaiitribune-herald.com · www.iltalehti.fi · www.parapolitika.gr · +6 more
- [● 32 SOURCES] Erik Slavin stated that hypothetical censorship of news for service members would constitute a red line. www.sadanews.ps · www.europesays.com · islamabadpost.com.pk · arabic.cnn.com · www.parapolitika.gr · +27 more
- [● 31 SOURCES] Lara Korte stated she was dismissed after telling a CBS reporter she works for the newspaper rather than the Pentagon or any administration. www.sadanews.ps · www.europesays.com · islamabadpost.com.pk · www.haberaktuel.com · arabic.cnn.com · +26 more
- [● 31 SOURCES] Stars and Stripes is a military news outlet that is partially funded by the Pentagon but maintains editorial independence. www.sadanews.ps · www.europesays.com · brandaktuell.at · www.haberaktuel.com · islamabadpost.com.pk · +26 more
- [● 26 SOURCES] The Pentagon dismissed the publisher, editor-in-chief, and a reporter from Stars and Stripes. www.sadanews.ps · www.europesays.com · www.stationgossip.com · thegardenmagazine.com · www.chinesepress.com · +21 more
- [● 21 SOURCES] Publisher Max Lederer stated his leadership philosophy and understanding of the newspaper's mission differed fundamentally from the Pentagon's direction. www.sadanews.ps · www.europesays.com · islamabadpost.com.pk · arabic.cnn.com · www.parapolitika.gr · +16 more
- [● 20 SOURCES] The plaintiffs allege their dismissals were retaliation for a report regarding deteriorating conditions aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln. www.europesays.com · srnnews.com · www.thewrap.com · www.washingtonexaminer.com · www.theguardian.com · +15 more
- [● 20 SOURCES] The lawsuit alleges the firings were linked to comments made during a CBS News interview regarding editorial independence. srnnews.com · www.thewrap.com · www.washingtonexaminer.com · www.theguardian.com · www.europesays.com · +15 more
- [● 18 SOURCES] The journalists are unlikely to prove the Pentagon violated their First Amendment rights. offthepress.com · internewscast.com · srnnews.com · www.haberaktuel.com · abc17news.com · +13 more
- [● 18 SOURCES] Judge Trevor McFadden denied a request for a temporary restraining order to halt the firings. offthepress.com · www.haberaktuel.com · internewscast.com · srnnews.com · abc17news.com · +13 more
- [● 13 SOURCES] The Pentagon installed an active-duty service member as deputy publisher without his knowledge. internewscast.com · srnnews.com · offthepress.com · abc17news.com · keyt.com · +8 more
Timeline
-
[POLITICS] 2 sourcesStars and Stripes former publisher claims Pentagon firings were retaliatory
Former Stars and Stripes publisher Max D. Lederer Jr. claims the Pentagon fired him and two journalists in retaliation for reporting on poor crew conditions aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln.
-
[POLITICS] 2 sourcesPentagon journalists lose court bid to reverse terminations
A federal judge rejected a bid by three Stars and Stripes journalists to block their firing by the Pentagon, ruling that their comments constituted “government speech” rather than protected private speech.
-
[POLITICS] 19 sourcesPentagon can proceed with firing Stars and Stripes journalists, judge rules
A federal judge ruled the Pentagon can proceed with firing three Stars and Stripes journalists, finding they likely did not prove First Amendment violations during their CBS News interviews.
-
[POLITICS] 2 sourcesStars and Stripes journalists sue Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth
Three Stars and Stripes journalists are suing Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and the Pentagon, alleging wrongful termination in retaliation for editorial independence and critical reporting.
-
[POLITICS] 28 sourcesStars and Stripes journalists sue Pentagon over alleged retaliatory firings
Three Stars and Stripes journalists are suing the Pentagon and Pete Hegseth, alleging their firings were unconstitutional retaliation for reporting on military conditions and defending editorial independence.
-
[POLITICS] 40 sourcesPentagon dismisses Stars and Stripes leadership over insubordination
The Pentagon has fired the publisher, editor-in-chief, and a reporter from Stars and Stripes, citing insubordination following media appearances that defended the outlet's editorial independence.
-
[INTERNATIONAL] 43 sourcesPentagon fires Stars and Stripes editor, publisher, and reporter
The Pentagon has fired the editor-in-chief, publisher, and a Middle East reporter of Stars and Stripes, citing insubordination following interviews regarding editorial independence and potential censorship.
Sources
961today.com · abc17news.com · aljazeera.com · anglophone-direct.com · arabic.cnn.com · arabnews.jp · archive.in.gr · bangordailynews.com · barbadosgazette.com · brandaktuell.at · brandonsun.com · businessdaily.gr · ca.sports.yahoo.com · castanet.net · cbsnews.com · chinesepress.com · conservativedailynews.com · dailycaller.com · dailycallernewsfoundation.org · deadline.com · diariodocentrodomundo.com.br · dnyuz.com · english.alsiasi.com · epochtimes.com · europesays.com · fehmarn24.de · finanzen.at · forbesliberia.com · fortune.com · fr.news.yahoo.com · freerepublic.com · gazetakosova.com · gulfnews.com · haberaktuel.com · hackernews.com · hawaiitribune-herald.com · hna.de · hotnews.ro · iltalehti.fi · independent.co.uk · indyturk.com · internacional.estadao.com.br · internewscast.com · irun.com · islamabadpost.com.pk · it-boltwise.de · joemygod.com · jovempan.com.br
This summary has been updated 11 times: see revision history