[CLSTR]
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · United States · 15 sources

started · updated

Part of situation: U.S. Supreme Court review of home distilling ban (2 clusters)

U.S. Supreme Court to review 1868 ban on home distilling

Supreme Court home distilling ban taxation power Reconstruction-era law Department of Justice v. McNutt

The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to review the constitutionality of an 1868 federal law that prohibits the distillation of spirits in private homes. The case, Department of Justice v. McNutt, arises from a legal dispute over whether Congress exceeded its taxation powers when it enacted the ban during the Reconstruction era.

Lower federal courts have reached conflicting conclusions on the matter. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the ban unconstitutional, stating it violates the taxation and necessary and proper clauses because it does not raise revenue and instead restricts activities that could be taxed. Conversely, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the ban, viewing it as a necessary means to prevent tax evasion by making inspections more effective.

The federal government maintains that the prohibition is essential to prevent producers from concealing operations in dwellings to evade excise taxes. Violators of the current law face criminal penalties, including fines of up to $10,000 and up to five years in prison. Oral arguments are expected early next year, with a decision anticipated by late June 2027.

Entities

Department of Justice · Donald Trump · Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals · Hobby Distillers Association · Scott McNutt · Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals · U.S. Supreme Court

Claims

What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.

Sources

Can Americans legally distill whiskey at home? U.S. Supreme Court drinks in case * WorldNetDaily * by Andrew Rice, The Center Square [opslens.com]
Supreme Court to hear challenge of 160-year-old ban on distilling liquor at home as Trump admin. weighs in [www.tag24.com]
A Tax Law That Raises No Tax: The Home Distilling Ban Reaches the Supreme Court [thewhiskeywash.com]
Supreme Court Agrees To Review A Reconstruction-era Ban On Distilling Spirits In Private Homes [vinnews.com]
The US Supreme Court will decide if Americans can legally distill liquor at home [astig.ph]
SCOTUS To Review Ban On Distilling Booze At Home [www.joemygod.com]
U.S. Supreme Court to Review 1868 Ban on Home Distilling of Spirits [kenya-today.com]
Supreme Court to review federal home distilling ban [sjvsun.com]
The Supreme Court Might Soon Clear The Way For You To Make Moonshine In Your Home [www.whiskeyriff.com]
Supreme Court agrees to consider federal ban on home distilleries [www.scotusblog.com]
U.S. Supreme Court to review 1868 federal ban on home distilling of liquor | Honolulu Star-Advertiser [www.staradvertiser.com]
Supreme Court agrees to review Reconstruction-era ban on distilling spirits in private homes [www.troyrecord.com]
Can Americans legally distill whiskey at home? U.S. Supreme Court drinks in case * WorldNetDaily * by Andrew Rice, The Center Square [www.wnd.com]
Supreme Court agrees to review a Reconstruction-era ban on distilling spirits in private homes [wtop.com]
Supreme Court agrees to review a Reconstruction-era ban on distilling spirits in private homes [nypost.com]